Date Rewarded: May 8th, 2008.
A Chomby was walking down a path one day when Jhudora appeared in front of it. "Solve this puzzle, and you may pass," she said.
Suppose you have a very long steel bar, with a regular pentagonal cross-section where each side of the pentagon is 2 cm in length. This bar will be suspended vertically over a very deep chasm. At the bottom end of the steel bar, there is a spherical steel weight with a diameter of 50 cm. Going up the bar, at every 3 metre increment, there is a spherical steel weight with a diameter of 30cm.
If the density of the steel is exactly 7.8 g/cm3, the steel can withstand a tensile stress of 400 MPa, and gravity is 9.81m/s2, what is the maximum possible length, in metres, that the bar can extend without breaking? Round down to the nearest metre, submit only a number (with no additional or extraneous information), and disregard any deformation of the bar or any other forces acting on the bar.
Prize

Steel Negg

Steel Negg
Click to show/hide solution
Using the stress equation [1]:
Now, we can calculate the force that the steel bar can withstand:
where g = 9.81 m/s2 is the gravitational acceleration.
Don't round anything yet. The mass is contributed by 3 components: the big sphere m1, small spheres m2, and the steel bar m3. Since all of them are steel, they have the same density. We have:
<=>[V1 + int(h/3) * V2 + A * h] * d = m
where h is the length of the steel bar, int is the floor function (every 3 meter, we have one small sphere), d = 7.8 g/cm3 = 7,800 kg/m3 is the density of steel, V1, V2 are the volumes of big and small spheres. The volume of the steel bar is the product of the crossed area with the length of the bar.
We can calculate V1, V2 by the sphere volume formula [4]:
V2 = 4/3 * pi * (r2)3 = 0.014137166941154 m3
where the radius r1 = d1/2 = 25 cm = 0.25 m, r2 = d2/2 = 15 cm = 0.15 m. Don't round both volume either. We already know A, so the equation now should be:
<=>int(h/3) * V2 + A * h = m/d - V1
We know the right hand side of the equation but the left hand side is a little bit tricky. So, we can do a method of trial-and-error to test. Solve h by the following equation:
<=>h = (m/d - V1)/(V2/3 + A) = 654.0200901109209 m
Using h = 654 m, the left hand side: int(h/3)* V2 + A * h = 3.5320. The right hand side: m/d - V1 = 3.5321 (good). Now increase h by 1 (h = 655 m) to see if the steel bar can still withstand. The left hand side: int(h/3)* V2 + A * h = 3.5327. The right hand side: m/d - V1 = 3.5321. (not good). Therefore, the answer is h = 654 m.
Results: 986 people guessed the correct answer earning themselves 2029 NP each.
References:
[1] Stress
[2] Regular pentagon area
[3] Newton's gravity law
[4] Sphere volume